Thursday, September 18, 2008

Notes on Rhetoric

Arrangement
  • how an essay or individual paragraphs are arranged
  • is it organized in the best way to achieve the purpose
  • how a writer structures the argument depends on the purpose and affect

The Classical Model

  • five part structure for a speech or an oratory
  • introduction or exordium, which in Latin means "beginning a web" introduces reader under discussion
  • introduction draws the readers attention by challenging them
  • a lot of times the introduction is where ethos is used

  • narration (narratio) this is factual information and the background material.
  • the narration beings the development
  • often appeals to pathos, because writer is trying to evoke an emotional response

  • confirmation(confirmatio) usually major part of text
  • has the proof or development to make the writer's argument
  • most specific and concrete detail in text
  • confirmation strongest appeal to logos

  • refutation(refutatio) addresses counterargument
  • bridge between writer's proof and conclusion

  • conclusion (peroratio) brings essay to a satisfying close
  • usually pathos and reminds the reader of the ethos said earlier
  • brings writer's idea together and answered the question, so what

Patterns of Development

  • another what to consider arrangement
  • is writer's purpose to compare and contrast, to narrate an event, to define a term
  • each suggest a method of organization or arrangement
  • include a range of logical ways to organize an enitre text or individual paragraphs or section

Narration

  • refers to telling a story or recounting a series of events
  • can be based on personal experience or on knowledge gained from reading or observation
  • chronology usually governs narration
  • includes concrete detail, a point of view, and sometimes dialogue
  • a story that supports your thesis
  • often writers use it as a way to enter into their topics

Description

  • closely allied with narration b/c both include specific details
  • emphasizes the senses by painting a picture of how something looks, sounds, smells, or feels
  • often used to establish a mood or atmosphere
  • often not an entire essay is descriptive
  • but description that is clear and vivid can make writing more persuasive
  • by asking readers to see and feel what you see and feel, they can empathize with you, your subject or your argument

Process Analysis

  • explains how something works
  • how something works or is done
  • how to improve a difficult situation or assemble a something
  • the key is clarity
  • important to explain a subject clearly and logically
  • with steps, stages, or phases of the process

Exemplification

  • providing facts, specific cases, or instances, turns a general idea into a concrete one
  • makes argument clear and more persuasive to reader
  • giving an example
  • Aristotle taught that examples are a type of logical proof called induction
  • which is a serious of specific examples that leads to a general conclusion

Comparison and Contrast

  • juxtaposing two things to highlight their differences and similarities
  • to analyze information carefully, often leads to insights into the nature of the information being analyzed
  • often required on examinations where you discuss the subtle differences or similarities in the methods, purpose, or style of two texts
  • can be organized in two ways: subject by subject or point by point
  • subject by subject the writer discusses all elements of one subject then turns to another.
  • point by point us organized around the specific points of a discussion

Classification and Division

  • important for readers to be able to sort out materials or ideas into major categories
  • by answering the question what goes where and why readers and writers can make connections between things that may otherwise seem unrelated
  • ready made categories such as single, married, divorced, or widowed
  • could be asked to analyze and essay that offers categories or to apply to them
  • mostly a writer is to develop their own categories to find a distinctive way of breaking down a larger idea or concept into parts

Definition

  • may lay the foundation or establish common ground or identifying areas or conflict to make sure the writer and audience are speaking the same language
  • defining a term is often the first step in a debate or disagreement
  • some cases it is only a paragraph but in others it is the purpose of the entire essay

Cause and Effect

  • analyzing causes that lead to certain effect or the effects that result from a cause is a powerful foundation for an argument
  • casual analysis depends on crystal clear logic, it is important to carefully trace a chain or cause and effect to recognize possible contributing causes
  • don't want to jump to conclusion that there is only one cause or result
  • don't want to mistake effect for an underlying cause
  • often signaled by a why in the title or the opening paragraph